Skip to content

Is Consolidation Smart?

Calculate whether a personal loan saves money compared to keeping your cards.

Step 1 of 3: Your current credit card debt

Debt balance ($)APR (%)

Total $10,000; weighted APR 22.36%. Leave unused balances blank.

The CFPB warns that a lower payment can mean a higher total cost and that consolidation often fails without lower spending.

Default example: $10,000 over 36 months at the Fed's 22.36% card benchmark, August 2026 (released October 7, 2026). Consolidating with an 11.9% Fed average APR, used here as a fee-free example, saves $1,876 in interest and cuts payments from $384 to $332. Stretching to 84 months cuts payments to $176 but adds $968 in cost. Estimate, not an offer.

  • All-in APR check
  • Break-even rate
  • No sign-up

Consolidation decision breakdown

Consolidation saves an estimated $1,876 when both paths use the loan's 36-month term. Your new monthly payment would be $332 for 36 months. Estimate, not an offer.

Side-by-side cost comparison over full repayment
Financial MetricKeep Current CardsConsolidation Loan
Starting debt balance$10,000$10,000
Gross loan amountNot applicable$10,000
Interest rate / APR22.36% APR11.9% all-in APR (no separate fee)
Payoff timeline36 months36 months
Monthly payment$384$332
Total interest charges$3,816$1,940
Origination fee$0 (existing cards)$0 (0%)
Total financing cost (interest + fees)$3,816$1,940
Total payments (principal + cost)$13,816$11,940
Total-payment difference at entered termsBaseline$1,876 lower

Separate the rate from the payoff speed

At the same 36-month term, the cards cost $13,816 in total payments and the loan costs $11,940. The loan costs $1,876 less on this equal-term comparison.

Break-even contract rate

The break-even consolidation rate for your cards over 36 months with a 0% fee is 22.36% contract rate. A lower contract rate saves money at this same term and fee; the all-in APR must also be below the weighted card APR, and the entered-term totals must show a saving.

Break-even contract rate by card rate and payoff timeline (5.0% fee withheld; November 2, 2026)
Current Card APR24 Months36 Months60 Months
18% card APR12.76%14.34%15.63%
22% card APR16.67%18.26%19.54%
26% card APR20.58%22.17%23.44%
30% card APR24.49%26.07%27.33%

Method note (assumed fee): Solved with binary search on monthly amortization. Assumes a 5.0% origination fee withheld from loan proceeds, requiring gross borrowing of $10,526 per $10,000 cleared. If a loan charges 0% in fees, the break-even rate equals the card APR exactly.

What this estimate leaves out

Calculations assume fixed interest rates, equal monthly installments and all payments made on time. They exclude daily billing differences, rate changes and costs you have not entered. No credit decision is made on this page. General educational information, not financial, legal or credit advice.

To compare alternatives, explore our sibling tools: the credit card payoff calculator evaluates avalanche and snowball self-payoff schedules; the personal loan refinance calculator compares replacing an existing personal loan; and the HELOC debt consolidation calculator evaluates home equity alternatives alongside their foreclosure risk.

When is debt consolidation a good idea?

Consolidation makes financial sense when the replacement debt costs less in total and its payment fits your budget. A same-term comparison separates the effect of a cheaper rate from the effect of taking longer to repay. The calculator then lets you change the loan term to see whether a smaller payment sacrifices that saving.

The NCUA describes consolidation as combining debts into one loan with one monthly payment. That changes how you repay the balance. It does not cancel the balance. Write down what you owe, each interest rate and the monthly amount you can sustain before comparing any offers.

Enter each balance and APR in the calculator. It adds the balances and computes their balance-weighted APR: sum of balance times APR, divided by total balance. Different rates and payment allocations make that an approximation. Our credit card payoff calculator handles cards separately and compares avalanche with snowball repayment.

How do I compare a loan offer with my cards?

Compare the same debt amount over the same payoff time first, including the money withheld as fees. Enter your card balances, rates and target payoff time. Then enter the loan quote and repayment term.

Use the APR from your offer with the separate fee set to zero, matching our HELOC debt calculator. Alternatively, enter the note rate before fees plus the origination fee. Never enter both a fee-inclusive APR and the same fee again.

With an assumed 5% fee withheld, clearing $10,000 requires borrowing $10,526. The fee is $526. If a lender quoted 11.9% before that fee, this would reduce same-term savings to $1,247. The numerical rate illustration uses the APR benchmark from Federal Reserve G.19, August 2026; the fee is an assumption, not a market average.

Check that the net proceeds cover the cards you intend to clear. A loan whose face amount equals your balances can leave a shortfall if a fee is deducted before disbursement. The model grosses up borrowing to cover that deduction and charges interest on the entire loan. It assumes the fee is withheld, with no separate cash payment.

What does the break-even rate tell me?

The break-even contract rate is the interest rate at which both repayment paths have equal total cost over the loan term for both paths. The dated matrix above applies an assumed withheld fee to several card rates and payoff times. It is a mathematical threshold, not a lender's approval rule or a published offer.

Without fees, equal balances and equal terms break even at the same rate. A withheld fee lowers the contract-rate threshold because the replacement principal must be larger. The all-in APR shown separately solves for the monthly rate that reproduces the payment using only the net funds received.

A quote below the table threshold still needs an affordability check. If the lender proposes another term, return to the total-payments row. A longer loan at a lower rate can still cost less in total; the total-payments row shows by how much. The savings verdict requires both a lower all-in APR at the same payoff term and lower total payments at your entered terms.

What are the downsides of consolidation?

Fees, an extended term and new card spending can erase the benefit of a lower rate. The CFPB's consolidation guidance warns that a smaller monthly payment may simply reflect a longer repayment period, with more paid overall. The calculator calls out that combination when payment falls while total cost rises.

  • Check the fee: a small rate discount may not recover the cost of a larger starting loan.
  • Check the term: compare the final repayment date as well as the monthly installment.
  • Plan for the cleared cards: the CFPB warns that taking on new debt often fails without lower spending.
  • Check the collateral: the CFPB warns that failing to repay debt secured by home equity can lead to foreclosure.
  • Check temporary rates: the CFPB warns that low “teaser” rates can expire and the lender may increase the rate afterward.
  • Check what is being sold: the CFPB warns that some consolidation promotions are debt settlement services charging upfront fees in return for promises to settle debts.

The CFPB also cautions that people whose debt problems have affected their credit probably will not qualify for low interest rates. The Federal Reserve benchmark is a historical average for a specified loan series. It does not establish the rate available to you, and it is not a quote for every term offered in this calculator.

Does debt consolidation hurt your credit?

It can hurt through an inquiry or a new account, while paying down card balances can reduce revolving utilization. The size and direction of your score change depend on your full credit profile. This calculator estimates dollars, not score points.

Credit effects to watch, checked November 2, 2026
ChangeWhat the primary source saysWhat to check
Hard inquiryFICO: one additional inquiry costs most people fewer than five points.Ask whether a rate check uses a soft or hard inquiry.
New accountExperian: opening any new loan may shorten average account age and hurt scores.Consider the new account alongside the rate saving.
Card utilizationNCUA: installment loans are excluded from the revolving utilization ratio.Confirm the cards are paid down; avoid rebuilding balances.

According to FICO's scoring explanation, payment history is 35% of the general score breakdown and amounts owed is 30%. The latter includes more than utilization alone. Those weights do not predict your individual point change. Paying on time remains relevant after the balances move to a new account.

Experian says hard inquiries remain on credit reports for two years and may affect scores for the first 12 months. This describes the inquiry, not a timetable for your overall score to recover.

Before closing a paid-off card, consider the utilization effect. FICO explains that closing an old or unused card removes available credit and increases the utilization ratio. Paying the balance off and closing the account are separate decisions.

Which consolidation route should I compare?

Compare the repayment structure, fees and collateral before choosing a route. The NCUA discusses consolidation loans and upfront costs. A personal loan comparison should use the exact rate, term and net proceeds in the quote rather than a generic “typical” rate range.

A balance transfer requires its own calculation: check its promotional period, transfer fee and the rate on any unpaid balance afterward. Do not put a temporary promotional rate into this fixed-rate calculator for the entire repayment period. Experian's balance-transfer guide explains the fees and introductory-rate structure.

For a home equity route, use the HELOC debt consolidation calculator. It models the home equity option separately. The CFPB's foreclosure warning matters even when the projected payment is smaller: the house becomes collateral for debt that was previously on cards.

If a new loan is too costly, NCUA guidance on debt management plans says participating creditors may lower rates or waive fees. Check participation and costs directly; this page assigns no assumed negotiated rate. If you already have an installment loan, the personal loan refinance calculator compares replacing that loan.

For the question “Is $20,000 in credit card debt a lot?”, see the card payoff calculator's affordability example. For a $50,000 loan payment example, see the HELOC debt comparison questions.

How can I clear $30,000 of debt in a year?

Start with the monthly payment needed to finish within the year, then compare it with your available repayment budget.

For $30,000 over 12 months at the default card rate, the model requires $2,813 a month and $3,756 in interest. The fee-free loan example requires $2,664 a month and $1,969 in interest. If neither payment fits, changing lenders alone does not make that deadline affordable.

Debt consolidation decision questions

What is the downside of getting a consolidation loan?

The main downsides are fees, a longer payoff schedule and the possibility of building new balances on the cleared cards. A smaller installment can still mean a larger lifetime cost. The CFPB warns about each of these risks. Check the total-payments comparison before treating a lower payment as a saving, and keep secured borrowing separate because failure to repay can put the home at risk.

Source: CFPB: What to know about consolidating credit card debt

How much will debt consolidation lower my credit score?

There is no reliable single point estimate for your overall score change. FICO says one additional inquiry takes fewer than five points off most people's scores, but that describes the inquiry alone. A new account and changes to revolving utilization can affect the outcome too. Experian notes that opening a new loan may reduce average account age. This tool does not predict credit scores.

Sources: myFICO: Do credit inquiries lower your FICO score?, Experian: Does Refinancing a Personal Loan Hurt Your Credit Score?, NCUA: Credit scores and credit utilization ratio

Can I get a loan to pay off another loan?

A replacement personal loan can refinance existing borrowing, subject to the lender's terms. Compare net proceeds, fees and total repayments with the loan you already have. An advertised rate alone does not establish a saving. If you are refinancing an installment loan rather than cards, use the personal loan refinance calculator linked above to compare its remaining schedule with the replacement schedule.

Source: Experian: Does Refinancing a Personal Loan Hurt Your Credit Score?

What is the best way to consolidate debt?

Choose a structure by comparing its full cost, affordable payment and collateral risk against keeping the existing debts. A personal loan, a promotional balance transfer and home equity borrowing need different assumptions. A temporary card promotion cannot be modeled as a permanent rate. Home equity borrowing adds foreclosure risk. Credit counseling is another route to investigate if new borrowing does not produce an affordable comparison.

Sources: CFPB: What to know about consolidating credit card debt, NCUA: Managing debt and Debt Management Plans

Why does Dave Ramsey say not to consolidate debt?

Ramsey Solutions objects that moving balances does not change borrowing habits. The CFPB separately warns that taking on new debt often fails unless spending falls. Apply that warning to your own plan: include the replacement payment and a way to avoid rebuilding the paid-off balances.

Sources: Ramsey Solutions: The truth about debt consolidation, CFPB: What to know about consolidating credit card debt

Can I get a Wells Fargo loan to pay off my credit card?

Wells Fargo's published personal-loan page describes consolidation borrowing, but its personal loans are available only to existing customers. Its published terms extend from 12 to 84 months and it lists no origination or closing fees. Those product terms were checked November 2, 2026. They do not establish your eligibility or the rate you would receive.

Sources: Wells Fargo: Personal Loans, Wells Fargo: Personal loan terms and rates

What is the biggest killer of credit scores?

Payment history is the largest category in FICO's general factor breakdown, at 35%; amounts owed is 30%. Those percentages are category weights, not the damage caused by one event. They cannot tell you how many points a missed payment or a consolidation loan will change your score. Use the comparison to assess repayment costs, and check your credit reports separately.

Source: myFICO: What is in your credit score?

Sources

  1. Ramsey Solutions: The truth about debt consolidation - Source for the Ramsey viewpoint only; checked November 2, 2026.
  2. Federal Reserve G.19 Consumer Credit (October 7, 2026) - August 2026 commercial bank interest rates; checked November 2, 2026.
  3. CFPB: What to know about consolidating credit card debt - Consumer Financial Protection Bureau guidance; checked November 2, 2026.
  4. NCUA: Credit scores and credit utilization ratio - National Credit Union Administration; checked November 2, 2026.
  5. NCUA: Debt consolidation options and terms - National Credit Union Administration; checked November 2, 2026.
  6. NCUA: Managing debt and Debt Management Plans - National Credit Union Administration; checked November 2, 2026.
  7. myFICO: Do credit inquiries lower your FICO score? - FICO scoring model guidelines; checked November 2, 2026.
  8. myFICO: What is in your credit score? - FICO credit scoring factor weights; checked November 2, 2026.
  9. Experian: Does Refinancing a Personal Loan Hurt Your Credit Score? - Experian credit education; checked November 2, 2026.
  10. Experian: Can You Transfer a Personal Loan to a Balance Transfer Card? - Experian credit education; checked November 2, 2026.
  11. myFICO: Will Closing a Credit Card Help My FICO Score? - Checked November 2, 2026.
  12. Wells Fargo: Personal Loans - Checked November 2, 2026.
  13. Wells Fargo: Personal loan terms and rates - Existing customers only; published terms and fees checked November 2, 2026.

Reviewed by Vitaliy Muradov, a real estate investor with extensive experience. See our editorial policy. Last reviewed November 2, 2026. See our calculation method. Estimates use fixed monthly payments.

More calculators

Calculators

  • HELOC calculatorYour HELOC limit, the interest-only payment and the payment after the draw period ends.
  • Home equity calculatorYour equity in dollars and percent, LTV and CLTV, and how much you may borrow at 80%, 85% and 90% caps.
  • Home equity loan calculatorYour fixed monthly payment, total interest and estimated maximum loan, next to a HELOC on the same amount.
  • Cash-out refi vs. HELOCKeep your mortgage and add a HELOC, or refinance for cash: which costs less over the years you choose.
  • Compare home equity optionsHELOC, home equity loan, cash-out refi, home equity investment, 401(k) loan: what each costs for your cash and timeline.
  • Home equity investmentWhat a shared-equity deal really costs: your payback, the total cost and the cost a year, next to a loan.
  • HELOC requirementsWhich lenders' published HELOC rules your numbers meet: CLTV cap, credit score, line amount, state and property.
  • HELOC payoff calculatorYour payment when the draw period ends and how extra payments shorten the payoff.
  • Texas HELOC calculatorYour Texas HELOC limit under the 80% homestead rule, the payment and the Texas rules that apply.
  • Solar panel costInstalled solar cost, energy production, bill savings, cash payback and payment comparisons.
  • Credit card payoff calculatorPayoff date or monthly budget for one or several cards, plus avalanche, snowball and a same-term personal loan.
  • Personal loan refinanceCompare refinancing with keeping a personal loan: payment, remaining interest and fees, fee gross-up and cost break-even.
  • Bathroom remodel costBuild a bathroom budget from Census spending or your quote, add a reserve and compare financing.
  • Kitchen remodel costPlan a kitchen remodel from Census spending or your quote, add a reserve and compare financing.
  • Window replacement costInstalled window budgets by quantity and quote, with cash and loan payment comparisons.
  • Cash-out refinance calculatorMaximum cash, new monthly payment and closing costs for conventional, FHA and VA refinances, next to keeping your mortgage and adding a HELOC.
  • Personal loan for card debtSize a loan to pay cards after withheld fees; compare payments, total costs and a break-even interest rate.

Guides with a calculator

  • Is HELOC interest deductible?When HELOC interest is tax deductible and what it saves above the standard deduction in 2025 or 2026.
  • HELOC on a rental or second homeBorrowing against a rental or second home, or against your home to buy one: line, payments, rent and lenders.
  • HELOC for debt consolidationPaying off credit cards with a HELOC or a personal loan: total cost, payment and payoff date.
  • HELOC for home improvementYour renovation budget with a cushion, whether it fits your line, and the interest and payment as you draw.
  • Home equity agreementContract terms, fees, liens and settlement rules, with a price-path stress test and a sourced provider comparison.
  • Home equity loan, bad creditCompare credit-score floors, equity room and payments across low-score borrowing options.
  • Consolidation loan, bad creditCompare loan payments, fees and full cost with card payoff; published terms and score guidance.
  • HELOC ratesCompare dated HELOC rates and estimate payments when rates rise.
  • Refinance a HELOCCompare 4 ways to refinance a HELOC before repayment starts: new line, home equity loan, lock option or cash-out refi. See payments and 5-year total costs.
  • No-appraisal home equitySee how a lender valuation changes your credit limit and which appraisal methods lenders publish.