Why can payments rise when draw ends?
Repaying principal can increase the monthly bill. The CFPB brochure distinguishes plans that include principal during draw from plans that allow interest-only payments. The brochure says some plans allow interest-only payments during draw; it also describes plans that require principal. Your agreement determines the payment schedule, so the calculator assumes interest-only draw payments only for the comparison.
Federal banking agencies’ July 1, 2014 guidance describes an outstanding balance becoming due as a balloon payment or being repaid through higher monthly payments, “resulting in payment shock.” It is guidance to financial institutions, not a promise of a replacement loan to borrowers.
For the default $50,000 balance at an example 8.00%, interest-only payments are $333 a month. Amortizing over 20 years raises that to $418, a difference of $85. These amounts come from the same math as the calculator. Change the balance, rate and repayment term to compare your agreement.
Compare four replacement routes
The calculator compares four routes against keeping your current loans. A separate lender workout is discussed below because its terms require a lender proposal.
New HELOC
A replacement line offers another draw schedule under its own agreement. The checked Bank of America, PNC and Fifth Third disclosures describe six-month introductory periods; Truist describes nine months. The calculator does not treat an introductory discount as a permanent rate. Enter the ongoing rate and the new line’s fees.
The CFPB brochure says variable-rate payments may change even without additional borrowing. Compare the new line’s ongoing rate as well as its first payment.
Fixed-rate home equity loan
The home equity loan row models a fixed rate and repayment schedule. In this model it replaces the HELOC balance, begins principal repayment immediately, and leaves the first mortgage unchanged. Enter the quoted term and upfront fees rather than assuming the line’s existing terms carry over.
Existing-line fixed-rate lock
Ten of the sixteen lenders publish an option to convert a variable balance into a fixed-rate advance. Figure’s fixed-rate product is not a lock on an existing variable balance. Where conversion fees are published, they range from $0 to $100. The table preserves limits and exceptions, including fees after origination and state restrictions.
A lock can have a higher rate: Huntington says the fixed rate is always higher, and Citizens says it will likely be higher than the current variable APR. Both fixed routes start at the same illustrative rate for comparison; this does not imply equal lender pricing. Replace both rates with quotes. The published lock terms do not establish a general exemption from appraisal, title or underwriting requirements.
U.S. Bank says you must lock before the draw period ends; after that, it says you may no longer convert a variable rate to a fixed rate. TD allows a fixed-rate option during draw or repayment, but its term cannot extend beyond the repayment period. Check your lender’s timing before treating the modeled lock as available.
Cash-out refinance
The cash-out row replaces both balances with one mortgage. The other rows retain the first mortgage, so their displayed costs also include its interest. Compare both the payment and ending debt over the same horizon in the cash-out versus HELOC calculator.
The cash-out rate starts at the imported Freddie Mac PMMS example of 7.24%, dated October 29, 2026, from its historical series. PMMS measures purchase loans; Freddie Mac says cash-out refinances generally have a slightly higher rate, so a cash-out quote may be higher. Freddie Mac puts refinance closing costs at 3% to 6% of loan principal. This is a refinance benchmark, not a cash-out quote. Here the starting fee is the lower end of that range multiplied by both balances; an edited fee remains your own dollar input.
Can the current lender renew or modify the line?
Renewal, refinancing and modification are alternatives addressed in the federal agencies’ 2014 guidance. It tells management to begin contacting borrowers well before scheduled end-of-draw dates and to monitor options such as draw-period extensions or interest-rate locks.
The guidance calls for programs based on a borrower’s reasonable ability to repay, sustainable payments, and orderly principal amortization. It also tells institutions offering modifications to explain eligibility and how to contact the lender or servicer. Ask what is available on your account; these supervisory expectations do not establish that you qualify or specify a new rate or term.
What requirements can affect a replacement loan?
Published limits vary by lender. Five of sixteen lenders publish a credit score floor, ranging from Spring EQ’s “as low as” 640 to 680 at Chase and Citizens. Citizens’ figure is from its Rhode Island default rate box. These are published product terms, not guaranteed refinance approvals.
Eight of sixteen publish equity caps ranging from 79.90% to 90%; PNC labels its range “Maximum LTVs.” Compare those disclosures with your combined mortgage and HELOC balances divided by home value in the requirements calculator. The checked pages do not publish maximum debt-to-income limits, so this page assigns no universal debt-to-income rejection threshold.
Check early closure terms before replacing a line
Early closure charges have lender-specific exceptions. Bank of America’s $450 fee within 36 months excludes lines under $25,000, Maryland properties and Texas homesteads. TD’s charge is waived when refinanced into a TD loan. BMO says a charge may apply, and Truist says repayment of costs may be required.
PNC’s reimbursement rule excludes Texas. Regions specifies third-party closing costs it paid and a Texas exception. Use the full terms in the table to enter your old line’s closure fee; do not assume every lender recovers all closing costs.
The CFPB warns that falling behind or failing to repay on schedule could mean losing your home. Replacing the loan does not remove that collateral risk. The calculator estimates payments and costs; it does not determine eligibility.
Can you refinance the first mortgage and keep the HELOC?
For a Fannie Mae limited cash-out refinance that leaves subordinate financing in place, its Selling Guide says the subordinate lien must be resubordinated to the new first mortgage. This means keeping the HELOC involves its lien position as well as its payment. Ask about the required subordination before assuming both existing line terms and a new first mortgage can proceed together.
Frequently asked questions about refinancing a HELOC
What disqualifies you from refinancing a HELOC?
Published credit and equity requirements vary by lender. Five of sixteen lenders in the dataset publish credit score floors from 640 to 680, and eight publish equity caps from 79.90% to 90%. Those are product disclosures, not a universal refinance approval rule. The checked pages do not publish maximum debt-to-income limits. Compare the individual disclosures rather than treating one lender’s cutoff as a market-wide requirement.
How much is the monthly payment on a $50,000 HELOC?
At the calculator’s example 8.00% rate, $50,000 costs $333 a month with interest-only payments. Amortizing the same balance over 20 years produces $418 a month, an increase of $85. These are model estimates, not an offer. Your contract’s rate, balance and repayment term determine the payment; enter them in the calculator rather than assuming this example matches your line.
What does Dave Ramsey say about HELOCs?
Ramsey’s page argues that a HELOC is designed to keep borrowers in debt longer. It recommends paying off debt using the debt snowball method and warns that a lender can foreclose on the home. This calculator compares replacement costs; it does not adopt Ramsey’s recommendation as an individualized borrowing decision.
What credit score is needed to refinance a HELOC?
There is no single floor in the checked lender disclosures. Five of sixteen publish minimum scores from 640 to 680: Spring EQ says “as low as” 640, Bank of America and U.S. Bank publish 660, and Chase and Citizens publish 680. Citizens’ figure comes from its Rhode Island default rate box. These are published product floors, not a guarantee that a refinance will be approved.
Do you have to refinance your first mortgage to get out of a HELOC?
No. Replacing only the HELOC leaves the first mortgage unchanged in this comparison. The new-line, home-equity-loan and existing-line-lock rows retain the first mortgage’s balance, rate and remaining term. The cash-out row replaces both balances. Use the same horizon to compare interest, fees and ending debt rather than deciding from the replacement rate alone. The calculator includes the first mortgage in every row.
What are the pros and cons of refinancing a HELOC?
Refinancing can change the payment and remaining debt, but adds fees and can increase interest costs; compare those amounts over the same horizon. A replacement with principal repayment can have a different payment from an interest-only line. A longer term can change the payment and the amount still owed at your chosen horizon. Freddie Mac puts refinance closing costs at 3% to 6% of principal. The CFPB warns that failure to repay can put the home at risk.
Can you refinance a HELOC into a fixed-rate loan?
A fixed-rate home equity loan is one replacement route modeled here. Ten of sixteen lenders also publish a lock on an existing variable balance; Figure’s fixed-rate product is excluded from that count. Lock rates need a separate quote: Huntington says its fixed rate is always higher, while Citizens says the lock APR will likely exceed the current variable APR. Compare both rates and the disclosed fees.
Can you refinance a HELOC with the same lender?
Yes, an in-house refinance or renewal is an option discussed in the federal banking agencies’ 2014 end-of-draw guidance. It asks institutions to explain available modification options, eligibility and how to contact the lender or servicer. It does not promise approval or a fee waiver. Existing-line locks are another published option at some lenders; where conversion fees are published in this dataset, they range from $0 to $100.
What happens to a HELOC when the draw period ends?
The CFPB brochure says the draw period is followed by a repayment period. It describes a repayment schedule or a balloon payment, depending on the agreement. The agencies’ 2014 guidance describes the resulting payment shock when principal is due or monthly payments rise. This calculator assumes interest-only draw payments followed by amortization; check whether that matches your contract before using the result.
How do closing costs compare across HELOC refinance options?
Use lender-specific fees rather than a universal cost ranking. Published lock conversion fees in the dataset range from $0 to $100, with limits and state exceptions shown in the table. Other lock fees are not always stated. Freddie Mac’s benchmark for refinancing generally is 3% to 6% of loan principal. The calculator lets you replace each starting fee with your own quote, including any old-line closure charge.
Sources
- Fannie Mae: Subordinate Financing - Resubordination when subordinate financing remains in place.
- Ramsey Solutions: What Is a HELOC? - Source for the attributed Ramsey FAQ.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What You Should Know About Home Equity Lines of Credit - Official federal brochure on HELOC borrowing, repayment terms, and home equity risk.
- Federal Reserve Board: Interagency Guidance on Home Equity Lines of Credit Nearing Their End-of-Draw Periods - Supervisory guidance on payment shock, refinancing, and prudent workout options.
- Federal Reserve Statistical Release H.15: Selected Interest Rates (Daily) - Bank prime loan rate (7.00% as of October 29, 2026; released October 30).
- Freddie Mac: Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS) - 30-year fixed-rate mortgage average (7.24% as of October 29, 2026).
- Freddie Mac: Understanding the Costs of Refinancing - Primary mortgage refinancing closing costs benchmark of 3% to 6%.
- HomeEquityCalcs 16-Lender HELOC Terms Dataset - Verified terms and fixed-rate lock options across 16 major US lenders (checked November 1, 2026).
More calculators
Calculators
- HELOC calculatorYour HELOC limit, the interest-only payment and the payment after the draw period ends.
- Home equity calculatorYour equity in dollars and percent, LTV and CLTV, and how much you may borrow at 80%, 85% and 90% caps.
- Home equity loan calculatorYour fixed monthly payment, total interest and estimated maximum loan, next to a HELOC on the same amount.
- Cash-out refi vs. HELOCKeep your mortgage and add a HELOC, or refinance for cash: which costs less over the years you choose.
- Compare home equity optionsHELOC, home equity loan, cash-out refi, home equity investment, 401(k) loan: what each costs for your cash and timeline.
- Home equity investmentWhat a shared-equity deal really costs: your payback, the total cost and the cost a year, next to a loan.
- HELOC requirementsWhich lenders' published HELOC rules your numbers meet: CLTV cap, credit score, line amount, state and property.
- HELOC payoff calculatorYour payment when the draw period ends and how extra payments shorten the payoff.
- Texas HELOC calculatorYour Texas HELOC limit under the 80% homestead rule, the payment and the Texas rules that apply.
- Solar panel costInstalled solar cost, energy production, bill savings, cash payback and payment comparisons.
- Credit card payoff calculatorPayoff date or monthly budget for one or several cards, plus avalanche, snowball and a same-term personal loan.
- Personal loan refinanceCompare refinancing with keeping a personal loan: payment, remaining interest and fees, fee gross-up and cost break-even.
- Bathroom remodel costBuild a bathroom budget from Census spending or your quote, add a reserve and compare financing.
- Kitchen remodel costPlan a kitchen remodel from Census spending or your quote, add a reserve and compare financing.
- Window replacement costInstalled window budgets by quantity and quote, with cash and loan payment comparisons.
- Cash-out refinance calculatorMaximum cash, new monthly payment and closing costs for conventional, FHA and VA refinances, next to keeping your mortgage and adding a HELOC.
- Personal loan for card debtSize a loan to pay cards after withheld fees; compare payments, total costs and a break-even interest rate.
Guides with a calculator
- Is HELOC interest deductible?When HELOC interest is tax deductible and what it saves above the standard deduction in 2025 or 2026.
- HELOC on a rental or second homeBorrowing against a rental or second home, or against your home to buy one: line, payments, rent and lenders.
- HELOC for debt consolidationPaying off credit cards with a HELOC or a personal loan: total cost, payment and payoff date.
- HELOC for home improvementYour renovation budget with a cushion, whether it fits your line, and the interest and payment as you draw.
- Home equity agreementContract terms, fees, liens and settlement rules, with a price-path stress test and a sourced provider comparison.
- Home equity loan, bad creditCompare credit-score floors, equity room and payments across low-score borrowing options.
- Consolidation loan, bad creditCompare loan payments, fees and full cost with card payoff; published terms and score guidance.
- Is debt consolidation a good idea?Calculate whether debt consolidation saves money. Compare total costs, fees and break-even rates before replacing card debt with a loan.
- HELOC ratesCompare dated HELOC rates and estimate payments when rates rise.
- No-appraisal home equitySee how a lender valuation changes your credit limit and which appraisal methods lenders publish.